Introduction: When Jesus left this earth to return to heaven, He promised in John 16:5-7 to send a replacement. That replacement is the Holy Spirit. In the remainder of that chapter in John, Jesus tells us the Holy Spirit will do many things for us. That includes guiding us into truth and revealing to us things that Jesus said His disciples could not bear hearing at present. If the Holy Spirit dwells in all believers and guides them into truth, what continued need is there for prophets? One answer is that 1 Corinthians 12:7-11 tells us that prophecy is a spiritual gift that is possessed by only some believers. And to “distinguish between spirits” is yet another gift given to only some believers. Does that mean that only certain believers have the authority to test a prophet? These questions demand some serious thought. So let’s dive into our study of the Bible and testing the prophets!
I. New Testament Prophets and Testing
A. Read 1 Corinthians 12:1-3. Is Paul giving us a test for a New Testament prophet? (Yes. A true prophet will only say certain things.)
1. What are those things that a true prophet says? (The most fundamental test is whether the prophet acknowledges that Jesus is Lord.)
2. How is Christianity different than religions that worship idols? (Idols are “mute.” They say nothing. Christians, however, are given the ability to speak words inspired by the Holy Spirit.)
B. Read 1 Corinthians 12:7-8. What are the kinds of things that the Holy Spirit would inspire a Christian to say? (Messages of knowledge and of wisdom. These messages promote “the common good.”)
1. What do you think is a message of knowledge?
2. How would it differ from a message of wisdom?
C. Read 1 Corinthians 12:10. Paul mentions the gift of “prophecy” in a way that makes it appear to be different than words of knowledge or wisdom. Is that how you understand this? (Paul says that they all come from the Holy Spirit. The fact that Paul says that “one” has wisdom and another knowledge, suggests that we are dealing with different people with different gifts.)
D. Read 1 Corinthians 12:28. Are these gifts listed in order of importance? Or do you get the sense that Paul has a list and they are not written in any order? (Read 1 Corinthians 12:31. Paul tells us that they are ranked because he uses the term “higher gifts.”)
1. Is the gift of prophecy a “high” gift? (It is ranked second!)
2. If prophecy is the second highest gift, what problem do you see based on your knowledge of human nature? (Some Christians covet a high gift. They may misrepresent having this gift. That is why testing is important.)
E. Read Acts 21:8-10. In two verses we are introduced to five prophets. Four of these prophets are unmarried sisters. This raises all sorts of questions in my mind. First, why would God need to give four women in the same household the gift of prophecy? Would not giving it to one sister be enough?
1. Second, we started out with the basic test that a true prophet will acknowledge that Jesus is Lord. But later we learned that the gift of prophecy is given to only a select number of people because it is the second ranked gift. Do you think that the test for this second-ranked gift is acknowledging that Jesus is God? (Every Christian should acknowledge that Jesus is God, but not all Christians are prophets.)
F. Read 1 Corinthians 14:29. Is this testing what a prophet says? (Yes.)
G. Read again 1 Corinthians 12:10. If all Christians are instructed to test the spirits, what additional ability does the Holy Spirit give to someone who possesses the special gift of discerning spirits? (Read 1 Thessalonians 5:20-21. All believers should test whether a spirit is from God, but there is also a special supernatural ability to recognize spiritual influences that are not immediately apparent from the message itself.)
H. Read Matthew 7:15-20. Here is another test of a prophet. How do you understand this test?
II. Old Testament Prophets and Testing
A. Read Deuteronomy 13:1-3. What tests for an Old Testament prophet do we find here? (The fundamental test of acknowledging the true God. But we also have the implied test that you would only consider a person a prophet if what was predicted “comes to pass.”)
1. Who is being tested here? (We are being tested, not the supposed prophet.)
2. What about us is being tested? (Whether you love God completely.)
a. How is that a test of whether someone is a true prophet? (The fundamental problem for a false prophet is leading the people away to serve other gods. If you completely love God, you will be very sensitive to words that will take you away from the true God.)
B. Read Deuteronomy 18:21–22. What additional test does Moses give us for determining whether someone is a true prophet? (If the prediction does not come true, the prophet has spoken presumptuously.)
C. Read Deuteronomy 13:4-5. What attitude toward God does a false prophet encourage? (Rebellion against God.)
D. Read Proverbs 17:11 and Proverbs 24:21-22. I hear some people say that Jesus was a rebel, and that somehow justifies rebellion against the government or the church. How do you understand these warnings and the idea that Jesus was a rebel? (This is an area in which caution is required. A general attitude of rebellion reveals both pride (Proverbs 16:18) and stupidity (Proverbs 12:1). God seeks someone who obeys Him rather than obeying humans who rebel against God. Acts 5:29.)
E. Do you see any common points between testing a New Testament prophet and an Old Testament prophet? (Both emphasize fidelity to the true God, consistency with what God has revealed, and rejection of messages leading people away from Him.)
III. Jonah the Prophet
A. Now that we have discussed testing a prophet to determine whether they speak for God, let’s look at an example of an Old Testament prophet. Read Jonah 1:1-2. Is Jonah a true prophet? (It says that God gave His “word” to Jonah.)
B. Read 2 Kings 14:23-25. What does Israel think of Jonah? (This tells us that Jonah prophesied military victories. Jonah must have been a national hero. Note, however, that the King of Israel was not a good man.)
C. Read Jonah 1:3. What does this prophet who is a national hero do with this assignment from God? (He runs away.)
1. Any idea why? (Jonah is asked to give a message from God to the enemy of Israel. This is a very different kind of assignment from God. The national hero does not want to help an enemy of the nation. More to that point, he does not want God to show mercy and spare Nineveh.)
D. Jonah’s story is that when he is on the boat, a storm arises, and Jonah confesses that the storm that seems about to kill everyone on the boat is likely due to God’s unhappiness with Jonah. Jonah is tossed overboard (at his suggestion), a big fish swallows Jonah and God rescues him. Read Jonah 3:1-3. What happens when God tells Jonah a second time to go to Nineveh? (He obeys.)
E. Read Jonah 3:4-5 and Jonah 3:8-10. What is the result of Jonah’s prophesying in Nineveh? (The people repent! They call out to the true God.)
F. Read Jonah 4:1. What do we learn about Jonah? (He did not share God’s view on whether the Ninevites should live.)
G. Read Jonah 4:2-3. Consider what we learned about testing a prophet. What score would you give Jonah in your test of a prophet? (Jonah initially rebelled against God. Jonah has a bad attitude toward the people of Nineveh. His “fruits” look suspect at best. But on the most fundamental test, whom does Jonah serve, he scores very well.)
1. What about the test about whether what a prophet predicts comes true? (Jonah’s message is found in Jonah 3:3-4. Jonah did not indicate this was a conditional prophecy. Perhaps he should have given what he says in Jonah 4:2, but we do not know whether God told him to make the prophecy conditional.)
2. Why do you think Jonah wants to die? (I think he is embarrassed that his prophecy did not come true. I think he hates the Ninevites and wants them to be destroyed. This prophecy is not in line with all of his favorable prior prophecies about Israel.)
H. Let’s discuss this lesson as a whole. We learned several tests for a true prophet. Then when we looked at the example of a true prophet from the Old Testament, we saw something different. What should we conclude from this study? (God sometimes uses badly flawed humans to be His prophets. This serves as a caution against quickly rejecting a person as a prophet.)
I. Friend, we have the obligation to test those who claim to be prophets. At the same time, we need to look to those who have the spiritual gift of testing prophets. God wants us to be open to the message of a prophet, but also to be cautious. Will you take prophecy seriously?
IV. Next week: Prophetic Authority and Relevance.
Copr. 2026, Bruce N. Cameron, J.D. Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. Suggested answers are found within parentheses. If you normally receive this lesson by e-mail, but it is lost one week, you can find it by clicking on this link: http://www.GoBible.org. Pray for the guidance of the Holy Spirit as you study.

