Introduction: What an amazing day for Jonah! He doesn’t get skinned
alive and his hide stretched out on a rock to tan. He doesn’t get a
limb or two removed. He does not get mortared up alive in some wall.
He wasn’t impaled on a post. None of the terrible things the
Assyrians had a reputation for doing to their enemies happened to
him. Instead, all the citizens of Nineveh, including the King,
accepted Jonah as a true prophet, accepted his God as the true God,
and all repented and turned away from sin. Imagine the stories that
Jonah will have to tell back at his home church! Consider the fund-raising potential of such a story! “Thousands of Truly Evil People
Repent in a Single Day” is the headline. Let’s jump into our study
of the Bible and read about the reaction to this fabulously
successful day of evangelism!

  1. Reports To Send Back Home

    1. Read Jonah 4:1-2. How does Jonah react to the smashing
      success of his message?

      1. Would Jonah make a great pastor?

      2. Imagine a Billy Graham evangelistic series resulting
        in a city-wide, top to bottom conversion. Then
        insert “Billy” into our Bible text instead of
        “Jonah.” Can you imagine it?

    2. What is wrong with Jonah? (He loves himself and his
      reputation more than he loves God or other people.)

    3. How can a person who has such a clear vision of God’s
      character so greatly misunderstand his own purpose in
      life? (Jonah obviously did not believe that being like God
      was the goal.)

    4. How do you think Jonah reacted to God’s mercy to him? Was
      he as upset about God showing him mercy as he was to God
      showing mercy on the people of Nineveh?

      1. Is this you? Are you upset when God shows mercy to
        people who have the same sins you have?

        1. What about worse sins than yours?

    5. Compare the King of Nineveh to Jonah. Which one would you
      choose to be your prophet? (Review Jonah 3:6-9.)

      1. Contrast the attitude of the King towards Jonah and
        Jonah’s attitude towards the King.

    6. Read Jonah 4:3. Do you agree with Jonah’s view of things?
      (My first reaction is to agree with Jonah. What useful
      purpose can this guy serve? He has to be “kick-started.”
      His attitude is destructive. He only considers himself.
      If he wants to die, let him. He certainly should retire
      from ministry.)

    7. Read Jonah 4:4. What is your answer to that question?

  2. Prophets

    1. Read Deuteronomy 18:20. What is the punishment for being a
      false prophet?

      1. Do you think Jonah had this in mind when he told God
        to just let him die ( Jonah 4:3)? (This certainly
        softens our feelings towards Jonah. Before, we were
        ready to let the bum die. Now we begin to understand
        why he wants to die.)

    2. Read Deuteronomy 18:21-22. Let’s put ourselves in Jonah’s
      place. Does this test apply to us?

      1. Applying the test, is Jonah a false prophet?

      2. Let’s revisit your answer to God’s question in Jonah
        4:4. Has Jonah a reason to be angry?

    3. On the face of it, we have Jonah’s prophecy of destruction
      in 40 days, and the unmistakable fact that it did not
      occur. You want to avoid the logical conclusion that
      Jonah is a false prophet. Why? Because he is such a great
      guy? (No. Because the entire story leads to the conclusion
      that God gave this message.)

    4. If you believe that all prophecy is conditional, based on
      God’s mercy, how can you ever apply the “prophet test” of
      Deuteronomy 18:21-22?

      1. Why can’t a false prophet say, “God changed His mind
        to show mercy on X?”

    5. Read Jonah 3:4. Do you believe this is exactly the message
      that God gave to Jonah? (From many years of listening to
      witnesses and examining witnesses, I know that the truth
      sometimes gets “shaded” by the emotions of the witness.
      Sometimes it is just plain dishonesty. Other times a
      witness believes every word he said is absolutely true. My
      belief is that Jonah “shaded” God’s message to eliminate
      the clear conditional nature of the warning. He could not
      eliminate the “40 days” part of the warning because it was
      critical. However, Jonah shaded out the conditional part
      of the prophecy. Intelligent listeners, like the King,
      realized that maybe Jonah had not told the entire story
      ( Jonah 3:9). Bottom line: I conclude Jonah is a false
      prophet because he has shaded the message from God. If
      Jonah had clearly conveyed the conditional nature of the
      message, then his reputation would be intact.)

    6. Read Jonah 4:4 again. What does this teach us about God?
      (I was ready to let Jonah die after hearing what he had to
      say in Jonah 4:1-2. God, however, shows mercy by trying to
      reason this out with Jonah. God sounds like He is in the
      role of a counselor.)

    7. We like the story of Jonah because God’s mercy to Jonah
      shows us that God will have mercy on us. Aside from the
      general issue of God’s mercy on everyone, why would God
      choose this guy as His prophet? Jonah is not just anyone,
      he is God’s chosen prophet. (Wayne Grudem’s book “The Gift
      of Prophecy in the New Testament and Today” presents the
      theory (which I believe is correct) that “New Testament”
      prophets (i.e. modern prophets) do not come under the
      Deuteronomy 18:21-22 prophet test. New Testament prophets
      are allowed to be wrong. As a result, it is our job to
      compare what the prophet says with what the Bible says and
      in that way we sort out the wheat from the chaff of modern
      prophets. I think the Jonah story shows us that God’s
      tolerance for nonsense among his prophets, even in the Old
      Testament, is greater than we might have believed.)

  3. Waiting for Vindication

    1. Read Jonah 4:5. What do you think Jonah hoped would happen
      to the city? (I think he was waiting to see fire fall from

      1. If I’m right about what Jonah was wishing would
        happen, what reason would he have to believe that God
        would send fire?

    2. Review Jonah 4:2 again. Is there any reasonable hope in
      this that God will send fire?

      1. If you say, “no,” then what reason would Jonah have
        to believe fire might come? (The only reason I can
        see is that Jonah offered to die when he learned that
        God was going to show mercy. Assuming Jonah has the
        defective character that he seems to have, his line
        of logic is that God considers me so important that
        He will destroy Nineveh now that I’ve told Him I
        would rather die than live.)

    3. Friend, the hope that shines out of this book could not be
      missed even by the blind. The violent, terrible Ninevites
      are spared by God’s grace when they turn to Him. God
      keeps tenderly working with the twisted Jonah to
      accomplish God’s goals on earth. Whether you have been
      outwardly evil, or outwardly a Christian with a twisted,
      selfish heart, God still wants to draw you closer to Him.
      Will you respond today?

  4. Next week: A Wind, a Worm, and a Plant.